Comparing the Results of Coagulation Tests on Blood Drawn by Venipuncture and Through Heparinized Tunneled Venous Access Devices in Pediatric Patients With Cancer
Purpose/Objectives: To compare the accuracy of three coagulation tests (prothrombin time (PT), activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), and fibrinogen (FBG)) performed on blood samples collected through heparinized tunneled venous access devices (TVADs) with those from venipuncture.
Design: Descriptive comparative with patients serving as their own controls.
Setting: Pediatric comprehensive care setting for children and adolescents experiencing catastrophic diseases.
Sample: 53 patients who had TVADs, had not received asparaginase during the previous 14 days, and had coagulation studies ordered. Patients ranged in age from 2-20 years (X = 9.2 years, SD = 5). The most common diagnoses were neuroblastoma and acute myelocytic leukemia.
Methods: Blood was collected through TVADs within seconds of collection of the venipuncture sample. The first 3 ml of blood from a TVAD was discarded; the research nurse then drew three sequential samples of 3 ml each. Laboratory personnel were blinded to the source of all four samples until all analyses had been completed.
Main Research Variables: PT, aPTT, and FBG.
Findings: For all patients, results of PT, aPTT, and FBG tests on each of the three blood samples obtained through the TVAD differed significantly from results of the same tests on blood obtained by venipuncture.
Conclusions: These findings indicate that neither a 6 ml, 9 ml, nor 12 ml discard from a heparinized TVAD is sufficient to yield clinically trustworthy PT, aPTT, or FBG values.
Implications for Nursing: Nurses who have been persuaded by patients or parents to withdraw blood samples for coagulation indicators from a TVAD rather than from a venipuncture should have access to this research-based information that the three indicators, particularly aPTT, differ significantly from each other as to make it unreliable and potentially unsafe to sample blood from a TVAD to assess coagulation.
Almadrones, L., Godbold, J., Raaf, J., & Ennis, J. (1987). Accuracy of activated partial thromboplastin time drawn through central venous catheters. <i>Oncology Nursing Forum</i>, <i>14</i>(2), 15--18.
Bark, C.J. (1970). Coagulation nondisease [Letter to the editor]. <i>New England Journal of Medicine</i>, <i>282</i>, 1214.
Barton, J.C., & Poon, M.C. (1986). Coagulation testing of Hickman catheter blood in patients with acute leukemia. <i>Archives of Internal Medicine</i>, <i>146</i>, 2165--2169.
Capizzi, R., & Holcenberg, J.S. (1993). Asparaginase. In J.F. Holland, E. Frei, R. Bast, D. Kufe, D. Morton, & R. Weichsebaum (Eds.), <i>Cancer Medicine</i> (3rd ed., pp. 796--805). Philadelphia: Lea and Febiger.
Cicala, R.S., Cannon, K., Larson, J.S., & Fabian, T.C. (1988). Evaluation of coagulation studies from heparinized arterial lines with use of Lab-Site high-pressure tubing. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>17</i>, 662--666.
Ellis, M.R., III (1993). Coagulopathy screening in children with heparinized central venous catheters. <i>Pediatrics</i>, <i>91</i>, 1147--1150.
Gregersen, R.A., Underhill, S.L., Detter, J.C., Schmer, G., & Lax, K. (1987). Accurate coagulation studies from heparinized radial artery catheters. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>16</i>, 686--693.
Hancock, R.D. (1993). Venipuncture vs. arterial catheter activated partial thromboplastin times in heparinized patients. <i>Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing</i>, <i>12</i>, 238--245.
Kajs, M. (1986). Comparison of coagulation values obtained by traditional venipuncture and intra-arterial line methods. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>15</i>, 622--627.
Kaplow, R. (1988). Comparison of two techniques for obtaining samples for coagulation studies: Venipuncture and intra-arterial line. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>17</i>, 651--653.
Konopad, E., Grace, M., Johnston, R., Noseworthy, T., & Shustack, A. (1992). Comparison of PT and aPTT values drawn by venipuncture and arterial line using three discard volumes. <i>American Journal of Critical Care</i>, <i>1</i>, 94--101.
Laxson, C.J., & Titler, M.G. (1994). Drawing coagulation studies from arterial lines: An integrative literature review. <i>American Journal of Critical Care</i>, <i>3</i>, 16--22.
Lew, J.K., Hutchinson, R., & Lin, E.S. (1991). Intra-arterial blood sampling for clotting studies. Effects of heparin contamination. <i>Anaesthesia</i>, <i>46</i>, 719--721.
Mayo, D.J., Dimond, E.P., Kramer, W., & Horne, M.K. (1996). Discard volumes necessary for clinically useful coagulation studies from heparinized Hickman catheters. <i>Oncology Nursing Forum</i>, <i>23</i>, 671--675.
Merenstein, G.B. (1971). Heparinized catheters and coagulation studies. <i>Journal of Pediatrics</i>, <i>79</i>, 117--119.
Molyneaux, R.D., Papciak, B., & Rorem, D.A. (1987). Coagulation studies and the indwelling heparinized catheter. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>16</i>, 20--23.
Nowak-Gottl, U., Werber, G., Ziemann, D., Ahlke, E., & Boos, J. (1996). Influence of two different Escherichia coli asparaginase preparations on fibrinolytic proteins in childhood ALL. <i>Haematologica</i>, <i>81</i>, 127--131.
Palermo, L.M., Andrews, R.W., & Ellison, N. (1980). Avoidance of heparin contamination in coagulation studies drawn from indwelling lines. <i>Anesthesia Analgesia</i>, <i>59</i>, 222--224.
Pinto, K.M. (1994). Accuracy of coagulation values obtained from a heparinized central venous catheter. <i>Oncology Nursing Forum</i>, <i>21</i>, 573--575.
Reihardt, A.C., Tonneson, A.S., Bracey, A., & Goodnough, S.K. (1987). Minimum discard volume from arterial catheters to obtain coagulation studies free of heparin effect. <i>Heart and Lung</i>, <i>16</i>, 699--705.
Richiuso, N. (1998). Accuracy of aPTT values drawn from heparinized arterial lines in children. <i>Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing</i>, <i>17</i>, 14--19.
van Genderen, P.J., Gomes, M., & Stibbe, J. (1994). The reliability of Hickman catheter blood for the assessment of activation markers of coagulation and fibrinolysis in patients with hematological malignancies. <i>Thrombosis Research</i>, <i>73</i>, 247--254.
Wiener, E.S., McGuire, P., Stolar, C.J., Rich, R.H., Albo, V.C., Ablin, A.R., et al. (1992). The CCSG prospective study of venous access devices: An analysis of insertions and causes for removal. <i>Journal of Pediatric Surgery</i>, <i>27</i>, 155--163.